Tallow as a Moisturizer: Why It’s Not for Everyone (+ Better Alternatives)

The skincare world is always swirling with trends—and one that’s resurfaced with bold claims and strong opinions is tallow as a facial moisturizer. Yes, we’re talking about rendered animal fat, usually from beef, being marketed as a miracle balm for the skin.

But does this ancestral remedy actually hold up in the modern skincare world?

As a Master Esthetician with 25 years of experience helping clients navigate everything from chronic acne to barrier repair, I’m often asked:"What are your thoughts on tallow?"

Let’s explore this together—from both sides.

What Is Tallow?

Tallow is a rendered form of animal fat, typically beef or sheep. It’s rich in fatty acids like palmitic, stearic, and oleic acid, and contains fat-soluble vitamins such as A, D, E, and K. Supporters claim that because its composition mimics our natural sebum, it’s a “bioavailable” and deeply nourishing moisturizer.

Ancestral skincare enthusiasts often praise tallow for its simplicity, purity, and its historical use in healing skin ailments.

But simplicity doesn’t always equal suitability.

So… is tallow just glorified lard?

Technically? No.

Culturally and marketing-wise? Kinda, yeah.

Let’s break it down:

The Technical Difference:

Tallow is rendered beef or mutton (sheep) fat.
Lard is rendered pork fat.

Both go through similar rendering processes (removing impurities, straining, sometimes whipping), and both are made of saturated and monounsaturated fats that have a thick, greasy consistency.

In Skincare They Act Pretty Similarly.

Both are:

Occlusive
Rich in fatty acids
Thick in texture
Naturally scented like the animal they came from
And yes, both can clog pores or trigger breakouts for many people

So while tallow has been rebranded in wellness circles as a sacred ancestral skin salve… at the end of the day, it’s still animal fat.

So Why Is Tallow Trending and Lard Isn't?

Marketing, plain and simple.

Tallow is linked to “ancestral health”, “paleo”, and “nose-to-tail” living
It’s positioned as “natural,” “bioavailable,” and “clean”
Lard never got the influencer glow-up—it still sounds like something from a 1950s kitchen, not a face balm

But the truth? The differences are more branding than biology.

✧ The Claimed Benefits of Tallow

Even as a skin expert who prefers more advanced formulas and generally woudn't recommend tallow, I believe it’s important to recognize what draws people to tallow:

Rich in Vitamins A, D, E & K – Nourish and support regeneration
Mimics natural sebum – Offers biocompatibility for dry, compromised skin
Deeply occlusive – Helps trap moisture and prevent water loss
Minimal ingredient count – Great for those avoiding synthetic preservatives
Sustainably sourced (when done right) – A byproduct of the meat industry
Potentially anti-inflammatory & antimicrobial – Thanks to its fatty acid profile

Used sparingly and in the right context, it may provide comfort for very dry or barrier-damaged skin—especially on the body or during extreme weather.

❌ The Cons of Tallow (And Why I Don’t Recommend It for Most Faces)

Despite its nutrient content, tallow is far from a universally safe or effective solution—particularly when it comes to facial skincare.

Here’s a comprehensive list of concerns:

Comedogenicity – Heavy and rich, it can clog pores and exacerbate breakouts especially in acne-prone or oily skin.
“Beefy” Odor – Even well-rendered tallow may retain an animal scent, often masked with fragrances that can trigger sensitivity or allergic reactions.
Not Vegan or Vegetarian Friendly – Tallow is an animal product, which doesn’t align with many modern clean beauty values.
Inconsistent Quality – Purity and quality varies. Tallow quality depends entirely on how it's sourced and rendered. Poorly rendered tallow may contain impurities, residual blood, or contaminants, and may not be shelf-stable. Grass-fed and purified sources are better but not always clearly labeled or traceable.
Lacks Comprehensive Skin Benefits – Tallow doesn’t contain hydrating humectants, peptides, ceramides, or antioxidants commonly found in well-formulated moisturizers.
No Water Content – Without hydration underneath, applying tallow can trap dryness in, not moisture.
Not Microbiome-Friendly – It lacks the prebiotics or barrier support agents to promote long-term skin balance.
Can Feel Greasy and Occlusive – Many users report that it feels heavy and waxy, especially under makeup.
Limited Research – Unlike clinically tested skincare, tallow’s benefits are mostly anecdotal, with little peer-reviewed backing.
Oxidation Risk – Tallow can go rancid if not stored correctly.
Often Combined with Essential Oils – These may cause irritation, especially for sensitive skin.
May Worsen Underlying Skin Conditions – Such as rosacea, seborrheic dermatitis, or fungal acne due to its fatty acid profile.

So, What’s Better Than Tallow?

If you're craving deep nourishment, barrier repair, and glowing skin—without the risk of clogged pores or beefy undertones

—look to formulations that blend science-backed ingredients with plant-based wisdom.

Here are some ingredients to look for when choosing a high-quality, modern moisturizer:

Hydrators (Humectants):

These draw water into the skin and keep it plump:

Glycerin
Sodium PCA
Sodium hyaluronate (hyaluronic acid)
Beta-glucan
Pentylene glycol

Barrier-Strengthening Lipids:

These mimic the skin’s natural oils and prevent moisture loss:

Ceramides (especially Ceramide NP, AP, or EOP)
Cholesterol
Phospholipids
Squalane (plant-derived)

Nourishing Plant Oils & Butters:

Look for lightweight, non-comedogenic options:

Jojoba oil – Closest to natural sebum
Safflower oil – Rich in linoleic acid, acne-friendly
Shea butter – Healing and softening (in balanced amounts)
Sea buckthorn oil – Vitamin-rich and anti-inflammatory
Rice bran, black cumin, or raspberry seed oil – Antioxidant-rich and soothing

Active Botanicals & Antioxidants:

These help calm inflammation, brighten skin, and fight environmental stress:

Green tea extract
Niacinamide (Vitamin B3)
Vitamin C (ascorbic acid or its derivatives)
Allantoin
Panthenol (Vitamin B5)

At UltraViolet, here are two moisturizers that outperform tallow.

🌙 LUNA LIBRA – Lightweight, Hydrating Barrier Cream

Perfect For: Normal to dry, sensitive, or post-treatment skin

Key Benefits:

✔ Ceramide NP – Strengthens skin barrier

✔ Jojoba & Shea – Non-comedogenic emollience

✔ Chlorella, Sea Salt, Laminaria – Antioxidant-rich + microbiome friendly

✔ Green tea polyphenols & Vitamin C – Calms, brightens, and protects

✔ Phospholipids + Lecithin – Skin-identical structure for better absorption

✔ Dimethicone – Smooths and seals without suffocating

Why It Wins: It offers water + lipid balance, making it far more effective than tallow, with a lighter, breathable finish and elegant layering compatibility.

🌿 REPARATIVE RESERVE – Rich Repair Balm

Perfect For: Dry, mature, inflamed, or post-procedure skin

Key Benefits:

✔ Shea, Jojoba, Safflower, Sea Buckthorn – Deep replenishment

✔ Astaxanthin – Ultra-potent antioxidant

✔ Black Cumin, Rice Bran, Raspberry Seed Oil – Inflammation & redness support

✔ Olive-Derived Emulsifiers – Gentle, non-irritating, barrier-strengthening

✔ Rosemary, Vitamin E – Natural preservation + repair

Why It Wins: A luxurious balm for those needing rejuvenation and recovery without the comedogenic risk of tallow or the irritation of synthetic fragrances.

The Expert Bottom Line

Tallow may seem like a simple, back-to-basics solution—but in skincare, “simple” doesn’t always mean “better.” It’s occlusive, heavy, animal-derived, and often problematic for modern skin concerns like breakouts, rosacea, and inflammation. There are much better options out there. Instead, seek out moisturizers with hydrating, reparative, and antioxidant-rich ingredients that work in harmony with the skin—not just on it.

Your skin is a dynamic, intelligent organ. It deserves more than a trend. It deserves care that’s as intentional as you are.

Best Sellers